Barefoot in the Streets and Loving It
Logan Brown
Utah State University
Don’t forget to Stretch. Ever. It will come back to haunt you. A couple years ago, I neglected to stretch and injured my knee playing in a game of lacrosse. Since then, running has been more of a chore than anything else. For years I have loved the feeling of the blood pumping through my veins, but the throbbing in my knee often makes me stop before the adrenaline will kill the pain. Afterwards, I curse myself for running on it. Medical experts tell me that I should keep on going, stretch it, and that there is no major damage to its structure. That’s all good and well, but I feel like I’m wearing an ankle weight. Now I am forced to find ways to cope with these very real consequences; one thing I’ve found is running barefoot.
A few months back, I decided to play ultimate Frisbee with some people up on campus at the spur of the moment. I was wearing sandals, but I still decided to give it a try. I just kicked off the flip-flops and figured I would just jog a bit and have fun. My knee didn't act up, and as soon as I felt the adrenaline I kicked up the pace a few notches. Soon I was sprinting across the field, diving for catches, and making sharp cuts (the same type which originally injured me when I was wearing cleats) with little-to-no pain. I thought my troubles with my knee were coming to an end. I went home, took some ibuprofen, iced my knee, and felt pretty good. Sure, my muscles were complaining, but it was from underuse and a bit of atrophy. I had probably lost almost two pounds of muscle in each leg since the injury; I went from running for hours on end to running for about a half-hour before needing a short break.
The next day, I blew the dust off my running shoes and laced 'em up. They fit like a glove; my feet had pounded their imprints into them, down to each toe. I was still a bit sore from the night before, but I didn't want to let that stop me. I stretched out a bit, and then took off out the door. After a block or two, I felt that old pain again in my knee. I stopped, stretched out thoroughly so as to not re-injure it, and then took off again, making sure to slow my pace. I took a couple of hills, some stairs, and pushed it on home to find that old throbbing waiting for me after I came down from my runner's high. I didn't know what to think. It burned away at my hope; I regretted running at all, and was in a sour mood for the rest of the day. I planned on going to play again next week, thinking it was the softness of the ground that made it easier for me. Boy, was I wrong.
In my shoes, I slipped around and had very little fun trying to keep up with the others. I felt that they now expected a level of competition out of me that I had shown last week, but was now not providing. I noticed a few of the guys were barefoot because it was hot, and I decided to sit down and shed my shoes. The grass felt cool under my feet, and after standing up and walking around barefoot, I stretched out a bit and got back in the game. My performance was like night and day. I now realized that barefoot, I felt lighter. I wanted to hop, skip, and jump. Even with nice running shoes, my feet felt like bricks. Okay, I may be exaggerating just a bit, but it did hurt, and with bare feet I felt free. I stripped down to nothing but shorts, and started helping to make plays happen. I was outpacing my competition, and feeling like a kid again. I almost threw my shoes in the trash when I got home. Since that day I’ve had the benefit of reading an article by Kara Vromittag, Ronald Calonje, and William W. Briner about athletes that compete barefoot.
Kara and her colleagues took a look at foot and ankle injuries in sports, comparing barefoot sports to similar shod sports. Their data suggest that the barefoot competitors have more adaptive pronation – or rolling one’s foot so as to raise the outer edge and press down on the inner edge – than their shod counterparts, which seems to help limit injury (Vromittag, 266). I may not be an expert, but I think Kara’s explanations were astute, and easy enough to understand that she persuaded me to try out barefoot running in earnest.
I’ve come to believe that walking, jogging, and running barefoot have quite a few perks to them. Most people do not realize it at first since they are still in an initial stage of reluctance or distain. I have heard, and taken the time to consider, almost all of the reasons against barefoot running before even trying it. It gets your feet dirty. You could step in something gross. You might hurt yourself, or even pick up a disease. Oh, and your mother may have told you not to. That about covers it. Have you ever heard someone say that you SHOULD run barefoot? I have. I have reason to believe it’s good for me physically, mentally, and possibly spiritually. Oh, let’s not forget monetarily. I know girls that spend a fortune on their kicks.
I used to dislike having dirty feet. My aunt used to make me take off my shoes so as to not track dirt and other miscellaneous “stuff” around her well manicured house. From a young age my feet were supposed to be shod. Or is it Shoed? I digress. I was told that I would not be allowed in school without them. If I entered a gas station with “no shirt, no shoes,” I would receive “no service.” After all, dirty feet are practically a crime. Or at least, that seems to be the idea I understood since I was a child. Since I started writing this paper, I’ve taken to walking around campus barefoot. I’ve only been stopped once or twice, but I generally ease peoples’ minds when I tell them that I carry a pair of flip-flops in my backpack to wear when needed, such as when I use a public restroom. When I’m home, I simply wash them just like I do my hands. I have, however, been told that there’s a rule that I have to wear footwear inside by the facilities coordinator in USU’s HYPR building. Good thing I had those flip-flops on hand.
Thanks to my overprotective mother whom I adore, I grew up asking if any number of possible activities would hurt. I was not allowed to play peewee football because my older brother had injured himself in high school. Anytime I brought up motorcycles, parachuting, hang gliding, or other seemingly dangerous activities, I was met with a, “You could get hurt SO bad doing that!” and at a young age, I began thinking that way. Walking the streets barefoot would probably give Mother a stroke just thinking about all the broken bottles, nails, thorns, and used drug needles I could step on. It’s as if I were to be walking through a dump with a blindfold on. Earlier this week I decided to walk back from campus to my apartment barefoot; the only thing that hurt was some horse chestnuts I failed to notice that had fallen among the grass. Everything else just felt… nice.
My feet have taken a pounding since the day I could move; Mother always said that I learned to run before I could walk. I was the fastest one in my class until I hit one of my growth spurts. My tendons became tight, and I had blinding pain in my heels. I was diagnosed with Calcaneal Apophysitis, or Sever’s Disease. Don’t freak out; it’s more of a ‘condition’ than a ‘disease.’ Everyone has a growth plate that fuses onto his or her heel, or calcaneous. Mine just happened to be made taught by my tight tendons, and when I would run the fused portion would undergo minute micro-fractures (Noffsinger). So when I talk about foot pain, I am talking about much more than a stubbed toe. I’m talking about the pain of broken bones.
Many runners can understand my feelings about foot pain. There are five main injuries to runners, commonly called The Big Five. “The five most common running injuries: Achilles tendonitis - chondromalacia (runner's knee) - iliotibial band (ITB) syndrome - plantar fasciitis and shinsplints.” The major causes of these injuries are overpronation, tight or un-stretched muscles, and overuse. (Burgess) Some studies find barefoot running to produce less pronation than running shoes, spiked golf shoes, or spiked cleats (Stacoff). While there is no direct connection between these two doctors or their studies, the material seems to speak for itself – barefoot running can help reduce overpronation and thus decrease the occurrence of the big five. Although, admittedly, it can neither prevent overuse nor can it force the runner to stretch.
While running barefoot may decrease the severity of some injuries, many people assert that there are larger numbers of stress fractures involved in running barefoot. One study showed large amounts of stress to be placed upon the metatarsals, which could possibly be enough to cause stress fractures (Milgrom). While this may or may not be true, another more recent study at Harvard by Dr. Lieberman gave rise to another conclusion:
“Fore-foot- and mid-foot-strike gaits were probably more common when humans ran barefoot or in minimal shoes, and may protect the feet and lower limbs from some of the impact-related injuries now experienced by a high percentage of runners.”
This incites many to question whether runners are undergoing this problem because of barefoot running, or whether they are training too hard, too fast, and are therefore injuring themselves before proper barefoot technique can protect their feet. If you search runner forums on sites like therunningbarefoot.com, barefootted.com, runnersworld.com, or barefootrunner.com, you’ll find many people who would attest to this either through appeals to common knowledge, scientific data, or their own rough experience.
There are other factors besides metatarsal stress that give runners cause to pause before leaving their shoes at home. Probably the biggest reason that runners don’t take up barefoot running after researching it is that it will hurt for a while until their bodies become accustomed to it. However, many people opposed o working out use this argument: they don’t want to go through the aches and pains of taking on a new form of working out; and that is exactly what barefoot running is to regular runners in shoes. They never finish the ‘break-in period,’ so they don’t get to appreciate what comes after.
I felt more in tune with my surroundings on that walk home than I do on nature hikes. I can feel the warmth of the earth under my feet as I cross the dirt, the coolness of the grass and the shade soothe my heat after the heat of the pavement, and the myriad of textures pull my focus to where I am, what I’m doing, and where I need to go. My mind clears itself to make room as I absorb more information from my surroundings. I revel in my clarity. My alertness stays with me after a short walk, and my mind feels like it’s more adept and ready to accept new information. My mind feels open and healthy.
While we’re on the subject of health, let’s talk about foot health. Once upon a time I had athlete’s foot. It’s arguably the most common foot fungus with which we will have to cope. Most fungi – or at least this one – thrive in warm, damp, dark places (Athlete’s). Okay, now think about this – since our feet each produce approximately half a pint of sweat each day, our shoes will catch a good portion of that (Discovery). Our shoes may sometimes be ventilated on the top and sides, but I have yet to see a pair with vents on the bottom, where most of the sweat just sits. Basically, we walk around in what are effectively petri dishes. Going barefoot airs our feet out, cools them down, and obviously allows light to do its trick by breaking down what spores – a.k.a. baby fungi – you may have. If any are on your feet, they won’t survive. Score yet another for healthy feet!
Unshod perambulating – yes, I did use a thesaurus – makes me feel better. My knees don’t ache nearly as much, and my feet feel better. I feel more alert, alive, and I’ll even venture to say younger. It may not appeal to you, but that’s okay. But, if you were to give it a try, I doubt you’ll go without hopping, skipping, jumping, or otherwise enjoying the freedom you’ll feel from your heels to your toes. You may just feel like a kid again. Go ahead, I double-dog dare you.
Bibliography
"Athlete's Foot-Cause." WebMD. 02 July 2008. Web. 08 Nov. 2010.
Burgess, Teri. "The BIG 5, the 5 Most Common Running Injuries - Injuries and Treatment Section - A Time-to-Run - Your On-line Running Information Magazine." A Time-to-Run Headquarters Site - Your Online Running Information Ezine/magazine. Web. 01 Nov. 2010.
"Discovery Health "Why Do Feet Stink?"" Discovery Health "Health Guides" 16 Nov. 2000. Web. 25 Oct. 2010.
Lieberman, DE, M Venkadesan, WA Werbel, AI Daoud, S D'Andrea, IS Davis, RO Mang'eni, and Y Pitsiladis. "Foot Strike Patterns and Collision Forces in Habitually Barefoot Versus Shod Runners." Nature. 463.7280 (2010): 531-5. Print.
Milgrom, C, A Finestone, N Sharkey, A Hamel, V Mandes, D Burr, A Arndt, and I Ekenman. "Metatarsal Strains Are Sufficient to Cause Fatigue Fracture During Cyclic Overloading." Foot & Ankle International / American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society [and] Swiss Foot and Ankle Society. 23.3 (2002): 230-5. Print.
Noffsinger, Mark A. "Sever Disease: EMedicine Orthopedic Surgery." EMedicine - Medical Reference. 9 Apr. 2009. Web. 1 Nov. 2010.
Stacoff, A, X Kälin, and E Stüssi. "The Effects of Shoes on the Torsion and Rearfoot Motion in Running." Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise. 23.4 (1991): 482-90. Print.
Vormittag, Kara, Ronald Calonje, and William W. Briner. "Foot and Ankle Injuries in the Barefoot Sports." Current Sports Medicine Reports 8.5 (2009): 262-266. SPORTDiscus with Full Text. EBSCO. Web. 5 Oct. 2010.